
'Hush' artist Jim Lee's Batman
Here we go, Batman graphic novels. Without tooting my own horn, pretty much got them all (because Flipkart provides all the titles and a hole in the wallet as a result). This isn’t just a hobby, it’s an obsession. Batman, unlike many other super heroes such as Spidey and Superman, is human. He wasn’t bitten by some atomic spider, nor is he an alien from out of space, he’s a man, just like you and me. This is what sets him apart from the other heroes and why many of us can relate to him.
Compared to most super hero graphic novels, I would argue it’s the Batman titles that well and truly sit on top. Drenched in dark themes stemming from Bruce Wayne’s parents being murdered right in front of him, his yearning to turnover a city immersed in crime, conflict shrouded in mystery derived from a capable group of psychotic villains and Batman’s own remarkable detective skills and resiliency to never give up… the Batman graphic novel, to say the least is always a treat. Plus, just like in Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight, I can never get enough of appearances made by his diabolical adversary, the Joker. He truly is the ultimate villain and a consummate rival for the Dark Knight.
We’ve put together a list of the Top 10 Greatest Batman Graphic Novels… even if you’re not familiar with the character, but enjoy an intense read with great art, this collection is a good place to start.
~~
Batman’s origin story and the main source of inspiration behind Christopher Nolan’s Batman Begins. Written by the legendary Frank Miller of Sin City/300 fame, in my opinion, this is the Batman story you must start with. It follows the birth of Bruce Wayne’s career as Batman, as well as, Jim Gordon’s humble beginnings as a member of Gotham City’s Police Department - told in unique parallel story telling from both characters. David Mazzucchelli’s artwork is subtle and retro, while Frank Miller’s storytelling is realistic and gritty and considering this was released in 1987 - much like all of Frank Miller’s work, it’s way ahead of its time. A definite classic.
This is one of the longest Batman graphic novels available - a proper opus from the all star combination of Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale and is nothing short of brilliant. Jeph is a veteran writer for DC comics and Marvel who worked heavily on the TV show Heroes, while you’ll remember Tim Sale’s artwork also from Heroes. I would go out on a limb and say Tim Sale is one of the best Batman illustrators I’ve come across. In terms of continuity, this is the follow up to Batman: Year One. Set very early in Batman’s career, The Long Halloween explores the relationship between the Dark Knight and Harvey Dent, Gotham’s District Attorney who goes on to become Batman’s dreaded enemy Two Face in the same story.
One could say this is very much an origin story for Harvey Dent/Two Face - add a mysterious plot line based around a serial killer with a panache for picking his victims on holidays, set with a mafioso backdrop and what you have is a very entertaining, very complete Batman graphic novel.
Note: I’ve been forced to purchase this twice, both the collectors set and just a regular copy, due to the fact the copy that comes with the Collector Set hasn’t been bound properly and the pages keep falling out. That being said - the Collector Set comes with two very cool action figures of Batman and the Joker designed by Tim Sale - if that’s a reason to go for a horribly bound copy. It might be a better option going with the more expensive library binding edition of The Long Halloween.
3. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Considered to be THE greatest Batman graphic novel, this was Frank Miller’s first go at the Batman story way back in 1986. Brought in by DC to give Batman a darker edge (especially compared to the campy Batman TV series we remember from the 60s); Miller explores an older, weathered Bruce Wayne who has voluntarily retired as the world’s greatest detective for over a decade, only to make a come back in a time when vigilantism is strongly frowned upon by society and media. Everything you love about the Batman story and the characters driven from it is prevalent in The Dark Knight Returns. Personal highlights would be the ‘final’ battle between Batman and Joker, as well as the portrayal of a very complex relationship between Batman and Superman.
What I find amazing is that even though this is 20 years old, it’s still extremely fresh, which is why it’s no surprise this is consistently considered a classic amongst all comic book lovers. This makes for an excellent Batman epilogue and exceptional conclusion to the Dark Knight’s tale.
Note: Avoid Miller’s 2001 sequel that followed, The Dark Knight Strikes Again. For the love of me, I still don’t understand what it’s about. If you’re OCD about having a complete collection though, it does look pretty on the bookshelf and the artwork is stunning.
Written by Alan Moore (Watchmen, From Hell anyone?) and illustrated by Brian Bolland, brutal would be the only way to describe this Batman story. Take that back, The Killing Joke isn’t a Batman story, it’s actually all about the Joker. Violent, twisted and in many ways quite tragic; if you’re looking for the ultimate Batman vs Joker story, this might be it. In fact it has been labeled as the ‘greatest Joker story ever told’ by many a critic. The basic premise from the Joker’s point of view - everyone has a tendency to tip over into an oblivion of madness due to circumstances beyond our control - in this case, this proves to be the backbone for Joker’s origin and his sordid plan running through the story. We’re also given a savage explanation as to why Commissioner Gordon’s daughter Barbara becomes a paraplegic and is forced to retire her alter ego, Batgirl. Masterful dialogue from the legendary Moore, matched by Bolland’s vibrant artwork, a rare glimpse on the Joker’s origin and it’s no surprise why this is considered one of the greatest graphic novels available.
My only gripe? It’s just not long enough.
5. Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth
This one is for all the readers who enjoy quality artwork… the ones who rate graphic above the novel. Dave McKean’s illustrations are vivid, breathtaking and unreal. You’re not going to see Batman and his various counterparts depicted in such surreal and creative fashion anywhere else. Grant Morrison’s story is macabre, psychological and anarchic much like the artwork. Here, Batman not only faces a number of his enemies (in their purest most psychotic form) but also faces his own inner demons. Isn’t a vigilante who dresses in a bat outfit and is obsessed with fighting crime just as insane as his counterparts? Besides the underlining plot structure of Arkham Asylum being taken over by the inmates led by the Joker; there are also flashbacks of Arkham Asylum’s history and how it becomes Gotham’s loony bin for the criminally insane - these segments in particular are ridiculously creepy.
If a Batman graphic novel could translate into a ‘grade A’ psychological horror movie, then A Serious House on Serious Earth would be the closest thing to it. Recommended for mature readers and with good reason.
Brought to you by Jeph Loeb and Jim Lee, in terms of DC getting a legendary writer and equally legendary artist to work together - this really is a match made in heaven. The story is modern and the artwork is a testament to this. Without any exaggeration, Jim Lee has completely outdone himself in Hush. The plot has got a bit of everything; flashbacks of Bruce Wayne’s childhood, the love tangle between Batman and Catwoman, the manner in which Bruce Wayne is perceived by Clark Kent and Lois Lane, a colourful collection of villains drawn to mesmerizing contemporary perfection, twists and turns driven from a constantly plotting mystery villain with extensive knowledge of Batman’s identity and past… in Hush, for once it’s not the Joker who is the center of all attention.
Here we have a modern take and a new villain, this is one of the few Batman graphic novels from the turn of the century that is worth reading both for the art and for the story.
Note: Would recommend you buy the complete edition with both Vol 1 and Vol 2 in one package, versus buying them separately.
Very much against superhero team ups and prefer to read about them in their individual form, which is why I was a little hesitant about JLA: Tower of Babel. But this ambiguous study of the Dark Knight is quite a telling tale of his character. Fueled by paranoia, Batman has developed a dossier that spells out his JLA teammate’s Achilles’ heals (out of fear that maybe one of them might turn evil). When Ra’s Al Ghul manages to get his hands on the documents, sh** well and truly hits the fan. Wouldn’t go as far as saying this plot line is genius or the art is ‘mind blowing,’ but it’s certainly entertaining. The climax especially, where the JLA are deciding whether Batman can remain a member or not.
Essentially, this tells us exactly how Batman might handle a situation where he finds himself fighting against his peers. Judging by the events in Tower of Babel, it certainly isn’t pretty, even for the mighty Superman.
8. Batman: Knightfall Pt. 1 & Batman: Knightfall Pt. 2
This series is epic. What happens when you pit Batman against a villain who is genuinely stronger than him and extremely clinical (unlike the Joker) in his planning of the Caped Crusader’s downfall? The central villain of Knightfall, Bane, might seem to be all brawn - no brains, but he actually proves to be one of Batman’s most formidable foes. Without spoiling anything, you also have the introduction of Jean Paul Valley, who takes over the cape from Bruce Wayne, as a far more violent, far less forgiving Batman. Gotta say, JPV’s modified Batman suit is very cool as well. This graphic novel is action packed and filled with tragedy, but there is also redemption. For the first time Bruce Wayne as Batman is quite literally broken and for the most part defeated.
The Man Who Laughs tells the story of Batman’s first encounter with the Joker (before he was even referred to as the Joker) and while admittedly this doesn’t really compare with Alan Moore’s The Killing Joke, it’s definitely a must read, especially if you’re a big fan of the perpetually grinning monster. Gruesome artwork depicting all the cardinal components we relate to the Clown Prince are presented in this; his weapon of choice - the toxic gas which kills, mutilates and adds an eerie smile to his victims (the opening pages are really quite scary), the notion that he never really has a concrete plan but rather has an uncanny ability to thrive in chaos, his inclination to convey his maniacal threats to Gotham via TV broadcasts, his utter disregard for human life and more than anything else the thorough ecstasy he feels when he finds himself head to head with Batman.
However, like the Killing Joke, I would argue that this graphic novel just isn’t long enough, but it would seem DC recognize this and have added a Batman Detective story as a filler for the latest edition.
10. Batman: A Death in the Family
A Death in the Family made it on this list for two reasons - the first being, this was the first Batman story where the readers determined a character’s outcome with a rather crass dial-in your verdict a la American Idol. In this case, the character in question is (or rather, was) Jason Todd, the second Robin, who had a reputation for being a brat amongst the hardcore Batman fans. The events in A Death in a Family effect Batman significantly and it becomes a running conflict for the hero in the graphic novels that follow. Essentially, this is the turning point in Batman’s relationship with the Joker, where Batman will no longer hesitate to kill his arch enemy versus repeatedly giving him the beating of his life and dumping him into Arkham.
The second reason, Joker really is in full effect here - crazy vicious with a truly diabolical plan that sees him become the UN Ambassador of Iran while being a nuclear weapon smuggler at the same time. A Death in the Family is a real political roller coaster and given when it was published, a fairly accurate sign of the times. If not to see a bad attitude Robin get his ass beat, it’s also fun to see Superman doing all that he can to stop Batman from killing his worst enemy.
–
It’s a bit presumptuous to label this the ‘10 Greatest,’ I do understand all of us have different tastes. Which is why, if you feel I’m missing out on any classic Batman tales, please be sure to plug them in the comment section… would love to get a couple of Batman recommendations from you!
I will take the safe route and say this wasn’t compiled in order of preference, but rather a recommendation in which order one could read these novels without getting overtly confused with back stories and such. I will say that Year One, The Long Halloween, The Dark Knight Returns, Hush and The Killing Joke are my personal favorites.
Also, I feel compelled to add a wild card entry at the end of this… The sequel to The Long Halloween, Batman: Dark Victory, again written by Jeph Loeb and illustrated by Tim Sale is just as brilliant as any of the novels mentioned in this list. If you really like The Long Halloween, chances are you’ll love Dark Victory. It works in the introduction of Dick Grayson and the beginnings of the first Robin. Works really well for the OCD collector, because it really is entertaining and isn’t just a book that will sit there unread.










